Fintech platforms capabilities comparison

Table of Contents:

Available Platforms:

– Orion Portfolio Solutions

  • Custom Indexing Solution
    Orion’s platform enables advisors to create personalized, tax-efficient portfolios at scale. Launched in 2018, it integrates proposal generation, trading, and reporting within a single system, streamlining the management of direct indexed portfolios.
  • Key Features
    • Personalization: Advisors can customize portfolios to align with clients’ specific needs, including ESG preferences, sector allocations, and individual security exclusions.
    • Tax Efficiency: The platform offers proactive tax-loss harvesting and tax-effective transitions, aiming to enhance after-tax returns for clients.
    • Scalability: Designed to save advisors significant time per high-net-worth account annually, facilitating efficient management of multiple client portfolios.
    • Integrated Technology: Combines proposal generation, trading, and reporting in one cohesive system, enhancing operational efficiency.

– AssetMark

  • Direct Indexing Offering
    AssetMark provides direct indexing solutions through its subsidiary, Adhesion Wealth, which specializes in delivering personalized investment strategies for advisors.
  • Key Features
    • Customizable Portfolios: Enables advisors to replicate index performance while tailoring portfolios to clients’ specific preferences and financial goals.
    • Tax Management: Offers tools for tax-efficient investing, including tax-loss harvesting, to help minimize clients’ tax liabilities.
    • Advisor Support: Provides dedicated support and resources to assist advisors in implementing and managing direct indexing strategies effectively.
    • Integration with Broader Services: As part of AssetMark’s platform, advisors can access a range of investment solutions and resources to meet diverse client needs.

– SEI

  • Direct Indexing Solutions
    SEI has expanded its Separately Managed Account (SMA) and Unified Managed Account (UMA) solutions to include direct indexing and factor investment strategies. These offerings were developed in response to client feedback and aim to enhance personalization and tax control for advisors and investors.
  • Key Features
    • Customization: SEI’s direct indexing allows for tailored investment strategies, including fixed income-based direct indexing and dividend-focused equity options. This enables advisors to align portfolios with clients’ specific financial goals and preferences.
    • Tax Efficiency: The platform emphasizes tax-efficient investing, providing tools for tax-loss harvesting and personalized tax management to help minimize clients’ tax liabilities.
    • Integration: SEI’s direct indexing solutions are integrated within their Managed Account Solutions program, offering a cohesive experience for advisors managing client portfolios.
    • Investment Strategies: SEI offers a range of strategies, including the Systematic U.S. Large Cap Core Strategy, Systematic U.S. All Cap Core Strategy, and Systematic International Developed Core (ADR) Strategy, each tracking specific indices with a focus on minimizing tracking error.

Comparison Table

ProviderCustomizationTax MgtESGTech IntegrationClientsMin InvestKey Features
SEIHighYesLimitedSeamless SMA/UMA integrationAdvisors, Institutions$100,000Dividend/fixed-income focus,
personalized tax management
EnvestnetHighYesYesBroadly integrated ecosystemAdvisors, RIAs, HNW clients$100,000Long-standing Quantitative Portfolios,
scalable for large firms
AssetMarkModerate–HighYesYesPart of AssetMark’s advisor platformAdvisors$250,000Adhesion Wealth support,
tailored direct indexing options
Orion Portfolio SolutionsHighYesYesIntegrate -d proposal, trading, reportingAdvisors, RIAs$100,000Modular interface,
tax-efficient transitions,
household-level customization

– Envestnet

  • Direct Indexing Solutions
    Envestnet provides direct indexing through its Quantitative Portfolios (QPs), which have been in the market for over nine years and position Envestnet as one of the largest direct indexing providers.
  • Key Features
    • Cost Efficiency: Envestnet’s direct indexing solutions are priced materially lower than actively managed SMAs, making them a cost-effective option for investors seeking personalized portfolios.
    • Personalization: The platform allows for easy personalization along traditional and more complex dimensions, such as factor-based strategies, enabling advisors to tailor portfolios to clients’ specific needs and preferences.
    • Integration: Envestnet’s direct indexing solutions are designed to be used with tax and/or impact overlays, providing a seamless integration for advisors looking to incorporate these elements into client portfolios.
    • Strategic Partnerships: Envestnet has partnered with asset managers like BlackRock and Fidelity to offer personalized direct index products within its Unified Managed Account (UMA) platform, enhancing the range of options available to advisors.

Detailed Comparison

– SEI

Strengths

  • Strong focus on personalization, including fixed-income and dividend-focused strategies.
  • Integrated within SEI’s managed account solutions, offering seamless access for advisors.
  • Emphasis on tracking error minimization and client-specific tax preferences.

Challenges

  • Limited ESG customization compared to other providers like Envestnet or Orion.
  • Less robust technology tools for multi-goal household-level customization.

– Envestnet

Strengths

  • Deep experience with direct indexing (over nine years of Quantitative Portfolios).
  • Scalable solution ideal for large advisor practices or institutional needs.
  • Comprehensive ESG options integrated across the Envestnet ecosystem.

Challenges

  • Higher minimum investment requirements could be a barrier for smaller practices.
  • Reliance on broader Envestnet tools may not suit standalone users.

– AssetMark

Strengths

  • Dedicated advisor support via Adhesion Wealth enhances onboarding and strategy deployment.
  • Balanced focus on tax-loss harvesting and personalized portfolios.
  • Broad integration with AssetMark’s other wealth management offerings.

Challenges

  • Higher minimum investment compared to some competitors.
  • Customization is not as flexible or technology-driven as Orion or Envestnet.

– Orion Portfolio Solutions

Strengths

  • Highly flexible, modular platform with end-to-end integration for proposals, trading, and reporting.
  • Strong focus on tax efficiency, including transitions for high-net-worth accounts.
  • Effective household-level customization, ideal for advisors managing multiple accounts per client.

Challenges

  • May require advisors to adapt to the specific workflows of Orion’s platform.
  • Less focus on specific investment strategies (e.g., dividends or factors) than SEI or Envestnet.

Key Takeaways

  • For Advisors Seeking Technology Integration: Orion Portfolio Solutions offers the most advanced and modular tech tools, enabling seamless portfolio management and customization.
  • For Large, Established Practices: Envestnet provides scalability, long-standing experience, and broad ESG capabilities ideal for high-net-worth and institutional clients.
  • For Personalization with Tax Emphasis: SEI focuses on precise strategies like fixed income and dividends with integrated tax solutions.
  • For Advisors Needing Support: AssetMark offers extensive resources and advisor-centric tools, making it a strong choice for those seeking guided implementation.

Each provider has unique strengths, and the choice will depend on the specific needs of advisors and their client base.

Offer personalized experiences for every client at scale

Table of Contents:

Are you a
Registered Investment Advisor?

Schedule a meeting with our experts!

Or provide your information and one of our team members will reach out to you.

Schedule a meeting with our experts!

Or provide your information and one of our team members will reach out to you.

Please provide your information and one of our team members will reach out to you.